Will have to wait until it's colder to start wearing, but this (J140) jacket was my favorite from the lineup. Classic canvas shell that feels very thick and durable. Will have to get broken in to loosen up a bit. Liner is soft flannel, doesn't feel snaggy. Sleeves are nylon which is great so your shirt sleeves don't get caught and bunch up.

Overall size is what I expected, fits pretty true but is a hair baggy if anything so movement is very good. Sleeves are a hair baggy but I'm not complaining. I like how the waist and (mainly) wrist cuffs are stretchy so they seal off air, but aren't tight at all.

Love Carhartt in general. Wanted something a little nicer than my old work jacket. This one looks really nice, but doesn't fit me well. I'm 5'8" and ~175lbs. Normally wear a Medium-Large depending on fit. I would call this a slim fit jacket-good if you have narrow waist/hips and more bulk in the chest/arms. It is super warm, even wearing it open. I might have returned it, but after an initial tryon that worked ok, I tore off tags and washed it. Didn't try it on with my EDC set up in place before washing it.

Bought the Medium based on the size chart vs my measurements. The shoulders are baggy and the arms are about inch long on me. Which isn't that bad as I have kind of a small frame. However, the bottom of the jacket is NARROW and inflexible! If I have anything sticking out of a pocket or attached to my belt, I can't start the zipper. Without anything on my belt, I can just barely get it started. :(

So, fits a little large in the shoulders and arms, but a little small in the waist.